W14.1 Ma Chenxiao마신소

 

Definitions and Distinctions

  • Race is defined as a human population distinguished by physical differences, such as skin color and facial characteristics. It is usually externally assigned rather than self-identified.
  • Ethnicity refers to social traits shared by a population, including nationality, language, religion, culture, and traditions. Unlike race, ethnicity is often self-identified.

Historical Perspectives on Race

  • Ancient classifications, such as those by Egyptians and Greeks, combined physical and tribal/national identities.
  • Scientific attempts to categorize race began in the 17th century, influenced by European imperialism. Early scientists categorized races based on physical traits and linked them to moral character and intelligence.

Changing Definitions of Race

  • Early definitions were essentialist and taxonomic, viewing races as fixed biological categories.
  • Darwinian evolution and genetics challenged these views, leading to modern perspectives that question the scientific validity of racial classifications.

Race as a Social Construct

  • Many sociologists and biologists now see race as a social construct, not a biological reality.
  • U.S. Census classifications have evolved, illustrating the changing and constructed nature of racial categories.

Race in Different Contexts: U.S. and Brazil

  • U.S.: Racial classifications have been used to maintain social hierarchies, especially through slavery and Native American land rights.
  • Brazil: The Brazilian Institute of Geography and Statistics uses categories like white, black, pardo (brown), yellow, and Indigenous. These categories show the fluid and socially constructed nature of race, with significant self-reporting biases like "self-lightening."

Biology, Genetics, and Race

  • Genetic studies can identify population structures but often reflect social constructions rather than empirical realities.
  • Genetic variation within racial groups is greater than between them, though some genetic conditions are more prevalent in certain populations.

Debate on Race in Biomedical Research

  • Proponents argue that considering race can improve healthcare outcomes by identifying disease risk factors and tailoring treatments.
  • Critics warn that using racial labels could perpetuate health disparities and historical scientific racism.

Interesting points

  1. Definitions of Race and Ethnicity:

    • Race is often seen as a human population distinguished by physical differences, whereas ethnicity refers to social traits shared by a population, such as nationality, language, and culture.
    • Race is typically assigned externally, while ethnicity is self-identified.

Discussion Topics

  1. Social vs. Biological Views of Race:

    • How do different academic disciplines approach the concept of race?
    • What are the implications of viewing race as a social construct versus a biological reality?

Comments

  1. CHENG SHIYIJune 3, 2024 at 1:20 AM

    I agree that race is a social concept, not just a biological classification. But this means that we should understand that race is not just about appearance or descent, but is also influenced by history and culture. In medical research, we need to be careful about using racial labels. While they can help us understand diseases and treatment options, their misuse can lead to widening health disparities and increased discrimination. So we need to be careful to ensure that our research does not exacerbate racial inequalities. By being careful with racial labels, we can better understand health issues and advocate for fair and inclusive medical practices.

    ReplyDelete
  2. 진화빙June 3, 2024 at 11:42 PM

    Different disciplines have different views on the concept of race. In biology, race was once seen as a group of people with common genetic characteristics; sociology and psychology emphasize the social and cultural construction of race. Viewing race as a social construction means that racial differences are more derived from social and cultural factors rather than pure biological characteristics. This helps us understand the social roots of racial discrimination and promote a more inclusive and equal society.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

April 29 (Mon) Kim Chae Eun

 1. Summary Arnett described the goal of socialization as follows. 1. Impulse control and development of conscience. 2. Preparing and performing roles, including professional roles, gender roles, and roles in institutions such as marriage and parental roles. 3. The source of meaning, the cultivation of what is important, valuable, and to live. Socialization is the process of preparing humans to function in social life. Socialization is relative to culture and does not force evaluation judgments. Since socialization is the adoption of culture, it differs from culture to culture and from subculture to culture. It should be noted that socialization is a key sociological process in the development of individuals who can function in human society, but not all aspects of human behavior are learned. Socialization is generally divided into two parts. Primary socialization occurs early in life in childhood and adolescence. Secondary socialization refers to socialization that occurs througho...
Read more

Introduction to the blog

This blog is a digital forum where students from Spring 2024 class in Invitation to Sociology at the Hanyang University in Korea will discuss their weekly readings and activities. Each week you are expected to post a blog post on at least 3 pages worth of the readings assigned for next week on our blog (here)  and make a comment on another student's post. As you are expected to do the assigned readings FOR the lectures they are assigned to, you are expected to post your blog and comments BEFORE that lecture. Deadline: Saturday midnight, for main blog posts and Sunday, midnight for comments. Exception: blog posts for the first week can be posted during the first week of class as if they were for the second week. An ideal commentary should be about a third of a page in length (~200 words), divided into three clearly labeled sections in which you: 1) summarize in your own words of materials you read; 2) mention any new, interesting, or unusual items learned; 3) identify at l...
Read more

W12.1 Blog for reading materials

1.Summary Goffman's dramaturgical theory has been applied to various social phenomena, including social movements, online identity construction, and theatrical performances. 2.Discussion The pursuit of essence is human beings' superficial understanding of things, and the pursuit of differences is human beings' deep understanding of things. Essence can be applied and labeled. It is a superficial understanding of things and is the process of people's understanding of the world. Lazy means. It is believed that as long as you master the essence of things, you have mastered everything about them, that is, you can transform cognition into action. Therefore, I believe that constructing essence is the first step to understand things, and constructing differences is the most important thing to understand things. People should construct their understanding of differences by constructing essence. Whether it is playing games, reading novels, getting drunk, or skydiving, all kinds o...
Read more